USD/CAD1.4298+0.29%EUR/CAD1.5736+0.01%GBP/CAD1.8860+0.06%Gold C$/oz5,515BTC C$93,229+0.01%ETH C$2,608-0.37%TSX35,722-1.06%S&P 5007,417-1.92%Dow51,608-1.41%Nasdaq24,510-2.49%BoC rate2.50%
e2goldCanada · money & markets
Trade and tariffs

Former ambassadors say Canada-U.S. trade deal possible but tariffs may remain

Two former ambassadors testified that a bilateral agreement could be reached soon, but warned a Democrat-controlled Congress is unlikely to end Trump's tariffs.

By the e2gold.ca newsroom ·
Former U.S. ambassador to Canada weighs in on trade war
Image: Global News

OTTAWA

A former United States ambassador to Canada says he is optimistic a bilateral trade deal is looming but cautioned Canadians not to expect a Democrat-controlled Congress to rein in President Donald Trump's tariffs.

"I am saddened by where the relationship stands today but I really do remain optimistic about its future," said David Cohen, who served as ambassador under former president Joe Biden.

"The ties between our countries run deep and I believe we have the foundation to rebuild trust, strengthen our partnership and move forward together."

Appearing by video at the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development in Ottawa on Monday, Cohen said the U.S. midterm elections were a historic rebuke of the Trump administration's policies.

But he is worried about "unrealistic optimism" from Canadians after Democrats said ending Trump's trade war with Canada will be a top priority when they become a Congressional majority in January.

Cohen said it will be very challenging for Democrats to convince enough Republicans to defy Trump over his signature economic policy in order to achieve the supermajority they need to bypass the president's veto powers.

Other observers have said Democrats will likely only tackle one of Trump's tariff tools, Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, while leaving in place other duties still hammering parts of the Canadian economy.

Cohen said Canada and the United States were close to an agreement before trade talks blew up at the eleventh hour in August.

He said Prime Minister Mark Carney was right to walk away from those talks.

"I think Canada has conducted itself extraordinarily well under a very intense and, I think, unfair set of pressures that have been created by U.S. trade policy by the current administration," Cohen said.

"I think Prime Minister Carney has played the hand that Canada has extraordinarily well."

Cohen said he is hopeful a bilateral agreement can be agreed by year's end or in January.

Last month, Trump said he expects a trade deal with Canada soon.

United States Trade Representative Jamieson Greer has said he wants to deliver "arrangements" for Canada and Mexico to the president by the year's end.

The Canada-U.S. relationship is durable but it may require a future U.S administration to apologize for Trump's rhetoric, Cohen added.

Former Canadian ambassador to Washington David MacNaughton, who served during the first Trump presidency, told the committee current negotiations are different and there may be no return to the Canada-U.S. relationship of that time.

"The fact of the matter is (Trump) had advisers who were sane and were trying to build a relationship that was good for both sides," MacNaughton said.

Now the president is surrounded by people who will agree with whatever Trump wants, he said.

The former ambassador said Greer, who played a role in CUSMA negotiations, is professional but ultimately the decisions come out of the White House.

MacNaughton said Canada should look to make a deal and find a tariff off-ramp but the bilateral relationship has ultimately changed.

He said Canada must diversify trade and boost domestic productivity.

"Let's diversify our trade but also let's find a way to get some kind of a long-term agreement with the United States back in place," he said.

"And thirdly, let us work on becoming more productive as a country because this does give us a chance."

Future of CUSMA in question

Even if a temporary agreement emerges, negotiations over the future of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement on trade will continue into next year.

The Trump administration in July chose not to renew the trilateral trade pact, known as CUSMA.

That triggered a rolling annual review for up to a decade, at which point the agreement will expire if the three countries cannot agree on an extension.

The Canada-U.S. relationship has been shaken by Trump's tariffs and threats of annexation but tensions rapidly escalated after negotiations between Ottawa and Washington broke down in August.

Trump used Section 338 to hit an array of Canadian goods with 50 per cent levies and weeks later, using the same Depression-era statute, banned imports of other Canadian goods, including motorcycles and some alcohol and dairy products.

The president also signed an executive order to rename Lake Ontario to Lake America.

e2gold.ca reported last week that Democrats' control of Congress and voter anger over tariffs created a new opening to restore free trade.

This story was written by the e2gold.ca newsroom from reporting by BNN Bloomberg, National Newswatch, CTV News and Winnipeg Sun. Quotes are checked word for word against that reporting.