USD/CAD1.4326+0.24%EUR/CAD1.5717-0.06%GBP/CAD1.8844-0.17%Gold C$/oz5,368BTC C$89,957-2.19%ETH C$2,545-1.21%TSX34,578-2.09%S&P 5007,324-0.23%Dow50,198-1.11%Nasdaq24,430+0.42%BoC rate2.50%
e2goldCanada · money & markets
Interest rates

Bank of Canada official warns too much forward guidance can stop markets from doing 'homework'

Deputy governor Toni Gravelle says sharing too much of a prospective rate path can lock policymakers into decisions.

By the e2gold.ca newsroom ·
The Bank of Canada tries to predict the future. It's not working out |  Radio-Canada.ca
Image: Radio-Canada

EDMONTON

A senior Bank of Canada official says monetary policymakers are trying to be more upfront about their thinking but there are good reasons why the central bank might keep its cards close to its chest.

Deputy governor Toni Gravelle gave a speech in Edmonton on Wednesday where he waded into an ongoing debate over how much forward guidance, a central banker’s term for where interest rates could head next, is appropriate to give.

Kevin Warsh, the new chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve, came out swinging against the practice of forward guidance as part of a major address in August.

He argued that sharing too much of a prospective rate path can lock monetary policymakers into future decisions or lead markets and households astray.

On Wednesday, Gravelle echoed Warsh’s concerns that too much forward guidance can leave markets parroting the Bank of Canada instead of reacting to incoming data that could shift the rate path.

"In a sense, they stop doing their homework," he told the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce.

"As a result, central banks can lose an important source of information about how investors view the economy."

Expectations about future interest rate movements are almost as important as the decisions themselves. Those expectations are baked into long-term bond yields and end up informing the rates offered to Canadians on many loans and savings instruments.

Gravelle said that the forward guidance debate is even more pronounced when the future is heavily uncertain.

The Bank of Canada has leaned more heavily on “scenarios” to inform interest rate decisions in times like this, he said, including back at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic or the start of the ongoing U.S. tariff campaign.

One such scenario outlined back in April where global oil prices stayed higher than initially forecast ended up closely mirroring the actual path for oil prices through the spring and summer, Gravelle said.

That helped inform the Bank of Canada’s decision to hike its benchmark interest rate for the first time in three years at the end of last month.

"In the April high oil price scenario, inflation stays close to three per cent for more than a year, and consecutive policy rate increases are needed to get inflation back to target," Gravelle recalled.

"In other words, the upside risk to inflation we had identified in April had largely materialized."

Outlining scenarios and possible reactions from the central bank can help Canadians better understand shifts in policy stance from the central bank, Gravelle said.

The Bank of Canada is committed to helping Canadians better understand interest rate decisions, he said, because that makes monetary policy work better.

The Bank of Canada’s policy rate stands at 2.5 per cent with its final decision of the year set for Dec. 9.

e2gold.ca reported last week that Governor Tiff Macklem will not seek a second term.

This story was written by the e2gold.ca newsroom from reporting by BNN Bloomberg and CTV News. Quotes are checked word for word against that reporting.