
SHENZHEN
Prime Minister Mark Carney says more competition, lower prices and better service will be key to any decision regarding the telecom sector.
The prime minister made the comments in China where he is attending the APEC summit after he was asked about Quebecor Inc.’s takeover offer for Telus Corp.
Carney declined to comment directly on the proposal, but said that under certain circumstances and depending on the market structure, an oligopoly situation can lead to more competition with fewer players, though he didn’t elaborate further.
“The objective will always be the best service for Canadians at the most competitive prices today and in the future,” Carney said.
The proposed deal would reduce the number of players in Canada’s wireless market, which is already dominated by just a handful of large telecommunication companies.
Telus, which is reviewing the unsolicited Quebecor offer, has said there would be serious regulatory issues with the bid that it also says undervalues the company.
Aidan Hollis, an economics professor at the University of Calgary, said it is not obvious the deal would be a pro-competition merger.
“A merger between two of the four major players would probably not be likely to lead to any substantial increase in efficiency that would result in lower prices,” he said.
Hollis said that in general, more industry players leads to greater competition, but that is not always the case.
“If you had a really inefficient competitor, that inefficient competitor might end up with a very small market share and potentially if they merge, you get a more efficient competitor who then is able to basically be a more effective competitor in the rest of the market,” he said.
If a merger doesn’t lead to greater efficiencies, Hollis said “What you could generally expect is as the market becomes more concentrated with fewer firms, there’s less need to compete aggressively by lower prices or a better service.”
Quebecor president and CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau has said he and Telus counterpart Victor Dodig are slated to meet next Monday to discuss next steps.
Péladeau has touted Quebecor as a fourth national carrier since his company acquired Freedom Mobile in 2023, as part of a deal associated with the larger takeover of Shaw by Rogers Communications Inc.
Some telecommunications analysts have cast doubt that the proposed merger with Telus will be completed, citing concerns about whether it would survive regulatory scrutiny.
RBC analyst Drew McReynolds called it a “major surprise,” but said he believes there is a “low probability” of the companies joining forces.
“Under the current regulatory environment, the required government approvals of a Quebecor-Telus combination without material remedies appears to us to be a non-starter, while such a combination alongside material remedies would naturally bring into question the combination’s underlying strategic rationale,” McReynolds said in a note on Monday.
e2gold.ca reported last week that Quebecor made a $31-billion unsolicited offer to acquire Telus, which the Montreal-based company said would create a strong pan-Canadian competitor.
This story was written by the e2gold.ca newsroom from reporting by BNN Bloomberg, CP24, Winnipeg Free Press and St. Catharines Standard. Quotes are checked word for word against that reporting.