
A new study commissioned for the Alto high-speed rail project says the proposed line connecting Quebec City and Toronto could increase Canada’s GDP by $24.5 billion per year.
The study, released on Friday from consulting firm Aviseo Conseil, says the project would strengthen Canada’s long-term productivity by increasing connectivity between major economic hubs.
“The economic significance of Alto goes beyond transportation,” Jean-Pierre Lessard, partner and cofounder at Aviseo Conseil, said in a news release.
“By bringing some of Canada’s major economic centres closer together, high-speed rail could help meet that growing demand while strengthening productivity and contributing to Canada’s long-term prosperity.”
The 1,000-kilometre project promises to connect Quebec City to Toronto in four hours and 30 minutes, with stops planned in Trois-Rivières, Laval, Montreal, Ottawa and Peterborough. The government estimates the project will cost between $60 and $90 billion.
The study identifies the Quebec City-Toronto corridor as Canada’s main economic centre, housing 41 per cent of Canada’s population and generating 40 per cent of its national GDP.
Aviseo’s study also finds there is a cost to inaction, stating that the corridor’s current transportation networks are facing “growing constraints that are increasing for travellers, in money, in time and in reliability.”
Air travel is suffering from limited competition, the firm claims, while VIA Rail suffers from having to share tracks with and yield to freight traffic.
“With the corridor’s population expected to grow by about 3 million people by 2050, these pressures will intensify in the absence of a structuring new option,” Aviseo’s analysis reads.
According to the study, intercity trips between the cities could increase from approximately 80 million today to 115 million by 2059.
“Without high-speed rail, this growth would be absorbed by existing networks, whose investment needs could exceed $50 billion for Québec and Ontario combined by 2050 under a status quo scenario,” Aviseo said.
“The question therefore is not so much whether to invest, but in which infrastructure.”
Lessard, an economist, said the project reduces economic distance, creating agglomeration effects. “You bring companies closer to each other, to their markets, their customers, their suppliers, the pools of workers, and this creates large-scale productivity gains that reverberate throughout the entire economy,” he said.
He argued that simply adding highways is not effective because they fill up due to induced demand. “That’s what Alto does: it cuts time in half, it’s speed, and that translates into economic benefits for all of Canada, all of Ontario, and all of Quebec.”
The study notes it is not a cost-benefit analysis, as precise cost information is not yet available. Alto estimates the cost at between $60 and $90 billion, while the Parliamentary Budget Officer suggested a figure of $75 to $113 billion earlier this year.
“We’re focusing on the overall economic benefits, and what we see is that they are substantial,” Lessard said. “When we talk about almost $25 billion per year, that’s 1.1 per cent of GDP.”
He said the work was submitted to an independent review committee made up of four experts from different universities across Canada.
Alto is aiming to begin construction on the first phase of the project, connecting Montreal to Ottawa, in 2029. The first phase is expected to take eight years to complete.
The project has faced opposition from many different stakeholders along the potential corridors, including landowners, several municipalities and politicians.
This story was written by the e2gold.ca newsroom from reporting by BNN Bloomberg, CTV News and CityNews. Quotes are checked word for word against that reporting.