USD/CAD1.4317-0.06%EUR/CAD1.5726+0.06%GBP/CAD1.8783-0.32%Gold C$/oz5,045BTC C$83,620-5.86%ETH C$2,297-8.80%TSX33,270-2.23%S&P 5006,910-3.70%Dow48,147-1.93%Nasdaq22,618-5.28%BoC rate2.50%
e2goldCanada · money & markets
Prices and inflation

Quebecor says Bell-Telus merger would harm consumers as takeover battle looms

The telecom company says a rival deal would worsen customer service issues, while its own bid would bring a 'breath of fresh air.'

By the e2gold.ca newsroom ·
Quebecor's $31B Telus takeover has just a 25% chance of closing, analyst  says. Péladeau points to Starlink as a reason for the merger : r/p
Image: Reddit

Quebecor Inc. says a potential merger between rivals BCE Inc. and Telus Corp. would harm consumers, as analysts predict a bidding war for the Vancouver-based telecom giant.

In a statement Thursday, Montreal-based Quebecor said a Bell-Telus combination “would not represent a positive outcome for consumers.”

“Bell’s track record with its customers speaks for itself,” the company said, pointing to consumer complaints and price increases.

“It should be noted that Telus has also engaged in such practices with its customers and was called to order by the CRTC for doing so. A merger of the two companies would only exacerbate these practices,” Quebecor said.

The company argued its own proposed takeover of Telus would instead bring “a breath of fresh air that would benefit Canadians.”

Quebecor announced a $31 billion unsolicited bid for Telus earlier this week. Telus has not accepted the proposal and said it is considering all strategic options.

That includes preliminary talks with Bell, which has hired financial and legal advisers to assess a potential transaction, The Globe and Mail reported.

Bell declined to comment on Quebecor’s statement. Telus also declined to comment on Bell’s reported interest.

Analysts say Bell’s involvement could spark a bidding war.

“It is natural for BCE to kick the tires on Telus,” said Desjardins analyst Jerome Dubreuil, citing the companies’ longstanding wireless network sharing agreement.

He said their networks are “fitting together like a glove.”

However, Dubreuil said regulatory approval would be a “long shot.” He estimated a combined Bell-Telus company would control 55 per cent of Canada’s wireless market, compared with 40 per cent for a Quebecor-Telus merger.

“A Bell-Telus merger would create significant synergies,” Dubreuil said.

He suggested Quebecor could end up as a “remedy partner” to a Bell-Telus deal, buying assets the companies might be required to sell to address competition concerns.

Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi said Bell’s entry could force Quebecor to improve its offer.

“If Quebecor thinks it can close this, Bell’s chances should be similar,” Yaghi said.

“Quebecor’s move may even push Bell to present a competing bid from which Quebecor could benefit when it comes to proposed remedies to get it through to the finish line.”

Telus CEO Victor Dodig has said Quebecor’s proposal undervalues his company and raised concerns about regulatory approval.

Special committee director Lisa de Wilde said the company is reviewing all possibilities.

“All options are on the table,” de Wilde told The Globe and Mail.

Quebecor made an initial approach to Telus on June 26 and submitted an enhanced proposal on Nov. 9.

Any major transaction would face scrutiny from the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.

Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said the government “will not predetermine the outcomes.”

Prime Minister Mark Carney said competition, lower prices and better service would be key to any decision.

Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau and Telus CEO Victor Dodig plan to meet on Nov. 23 to discuss Quebecor’s proposal.

The company said the interest from both Quebecor and Bell points to a need to strengthen Canada’s telecom sector.

“The interest successively shown by Quebecor and then Bell in Telus points to the same reality: Canada’s telecommunications sector must be strengthened, particularly in the face of new American technology and satellite players,” Quebecor said.

e2gold.ca reported earlier this month that Quebecor’s initial $31 billion bid for Telus raised concerns about regulatory approval.

This story was written by the e2gold.ca newsroom from reporting by The Globe and Mail, Global News, cwibc.co.id and SuaraGarut.ID. Quotes are checked word for word against that reporting.